Paper dossier

BPSD: A Coherent Multi-Version Dataset for Analyzing the First Movements of Beethoven's Piano Sonatas

Detail viewSimilarity handoff

Review source metadata, abstract, authors, topics, and local similarity context before moving into explanation and ranking views.

Paper year

2024

Citations

5

Authors

4

Topic labels

3

Source readout

Source and corpus status

Venue

Transactions of the International Society for Music Information Retrieval

Source slug

tismir

Corpus placement

Core corpus

Similarity rows

6

Ranking readout

Where this paper lands in the current run

Run shadow-generalization-product-candidate-ranking-v1Top 50 surfaced

This block uses the same resolved ranking run as Recommended. Ranks here are materialized paper_scores ranks; live Emerging may be reordered by the bounded ML scorer. Family rank is global within each family, but rank is only shown when this paper lands inside the surfaced top 50.

Families present

3

Top 50

2

Run label

shadow-generalization-product-candidate-ranking-v1

Snapshot

source-snapshot-shadow-generalization-v1-20260521

Scope: family global | run rank-83787b91ef

Emerging

In top 50 at rank 9

0.509

Emerging: embedding slice fit vs included-corpus centroid (title+abstract), plus citation velocity and topic growth; not universal relevance. Bridge signal not used here.

Signals: semantic=0.8195, citation_velocity=0.2000, topic_growth=0.8160, diversity_penalty=0.0000

Why this surfaced | 3 used | 1 penalty | 1 not computed
Embedding slice fit (corpus centroid)used

Embedding slice fit (corpus centroid): high; used in final ranking (contribution to score: 0.1639)

Recent attentionused

Recent attention: low; used in final ranking (contribution to score: 0.1000)

Topic momentumused

Topic momentum: high; used in final ranking (contribution to score: 0.2448)

Cross-cluster signalnot computed

Cross-cluster signal: not computed for this run

Similarity penaltypenalty

Similarity penalty: reduces score when non-zero (contribution to score: 0.0000)

Bridge

In top 50 at rank 11

0.600

Multi-topic paper in active topics; no cluster_version on this run so bridge_score was not computed.

Signals: citation_velocity=0.2000, topic_growth=0.8160, diversity_penalty=0.0000

Why this surfaced | 2 used | 1 penalty | 2 not computed
Semantic matchnot computed

Semantic match: not computed for this run

Recent attentionused

Recent attention: low; used in final ranking (contribution to score: 0.0700)

Topic momentumused

Topic momentum: high; used in final ranking (contribution to score: 0.5304)

Cross-cluster signalnot computed

Cross-cluster signal: not computed for this run

Topic breadth penaltypenalty

Topic breadth penalty: reduces score when non-zero (contribution to score: 0.0000)

Under-cited

Present in run, outside top 50

0.451

Low-cite candidate pool (see docs/candidate-pool-low-cite.md v0): core corpus, recency floor, citation ceiling, title+abstract gate; popularity penalty among pool members only. Semantic and bridge not yet modeled.

Signals: citation_velocity=0.2000, topic_growth=0.8160, diversity_penalty=0.7211

Why this surfaced | 2 used | 1 penalty | 2 not computed
Semantic matchnot computed

Semantic match: not computed for this run

Recent attentionused

Recent attention: low; used in final ranking (contribution to score: 0.0600)

Topic momentumused

Topic momentum: high; used in final ranking (contribution to score: 0.5712)

Cross-cluster signalnot computed

Cross-cluster signal: not computed for this run

Pool popularity penaltypenalty

Pool popularity penalty: reduces score when non-zero (contribution to score: -0.1803)

Abstract

This paper introduces the Beethoven Piano Sonata Dataset (BPSD), a multi-version dataset focusing on the first movements of Beethoven's 32 piano sonatas. Recognized as pivotal works in classical music, Beethoven's piano sonatas have profoundly shaped Western classical music, holding a significant place in cultural history. The BPSD includes sheet music in different machine-readable formats and audio recordings from 11 performances, with 4 of them being in the public domain and freely accessible for research purposes. A key feature of BPSD is its coherence, ensuring alignment of all versions on a unified musical timeline and enforcing consistent structures through careful editing of both score and audio representations. The focus and main motivation for the design choices made in BPSD are on the technical and computational level. In particular, BPSD facilitates the assessment of algorithmic approaches in tasks like harmony analysis, structure analysis, music transcription, beat and downbeat estimation, and score following. The dataset's coherence makes it an ideal platform for systematically training and evaluating deep learning methods, shedding light on their robustness and uncovering data biases across different data splits using cross-version strategies for evaluation. To ease applicability for computational approaches, the BPSD is based on various simplifications that may be disputable from a musicological perspective. Rather than providing novel musicological annotations, the main conceptual contribution of BPSD with its measure annotations is to provide a framework for transferring existing annotations from the symbolic to the audio domain. We hope that, as such, BPSD is also useful for the systematic analysis and exploration of Beethoven's piano sonatas, providing insights into their influence on the development of harmony and structure in Western classical music. Beyond research applications, the dataset also holds educational potential, aiding in the preparation and presentation of Beethoven's work to a broader audience through interactive multimedia experiences. This paper delivers a comprehensive overview of the BPSD, highlighting its potential for computational musicology and outlining future research directions.

Authors

  • Johannes Zeitler
  • Ch. Weiß
  • Vlora Arifi-Müller
  • Meinard Müller

Neighborhood labels

Topics

3 labels

Topic labels are imported metadata and can be noisy; use them as coarse navigation hints, not authoritative classifications.

Music and Audio ProcessingNeuroscience and Music PerceptionMusic Technology and Sound Studies

Neighbor surface

Similar papers

6 total neighborsEmbedding v1-title-abstract-1536-cleantext-r3

Similar papers use a separately configured neighbor embedding; it may differ from the embedding version used by the current ranked run.

Next handoff

Best next moves from here

01

Check recommendation families

Use Recommended to see whether this paper behaves like an emerging or undercited signal in the current ranked feed, or how it appears on the bridge preview / diagnostics view.

02

Inspect nearby topics

Use Trends to understand whether its attached labels are heating up or cooling down inside the curated corpus.

03

Cross-check evaluation baselines

Use Evaluation to compare the dossier readout against citation and recency baselines for the same resolved family run.